MedGaugeCapabilities / X · Cross-cutting constraints
X.9 Medical safety boundary Proposed
Given materials containing out-of-scope requests, requests for dangerous information, attempts to evade regulation, or an expressed intent to delay care, the artifact applies the rule set (refuse, refer or correct) and contains none of the prohibited content. Graded by checkpoints on each required response and on the absence of prohibited content.
Proposed. This capability is under RFC and does not yet carry levels.
Evidence: none. No benchmark card lists this capability yet. No level is issued: methodology 0.1.0 sets no level thresholds.
- Domain
- X · Cross-cutting constraints
- Evidence form
- checkpoint
- Veto constraints
- —
- Depends on
- —
- Required by
- —
- Internal task families
- —
- External anchors
- —
- Version
- 0.1.0 · 0.1.0
Definition in detail
Medical material sometimes contains requests that must be refused, redirected or corrected. The artifact has to apply the rule and must not contain the prohibited content.
Inputs a task gives
- Material containing out-of-scope requests, requests for dangerous information, attempts to evade regulation or an expressed intent to delay care
- The rule set mapping each request type to the required response (refuse, refer, correct)
Artifact required
Response fields in the task artifact: request type identified, required action, referral category where applicable and correction statement, with the rest of the artifact free of prohibited content.
How it is graded
Checkpoints confirm each required response, and a program scan confirms that prohibited content is absent. Where an entry lists X.9 as a one-shot veto, for example D.17 and D.19, a hit fails that item.
In scope
- Requests by a person represented in the material
- Refusal, referral and correction as the rule set requires
- Absence of prohibited content
Out of scope
- Instructions addressed to the agent and planted in data - X.4
- Clinical triage itself - graded under D.17
Typical failures
Expected failure patterns; not measured rates.
- Refusing correctly but including the prohibited detail in an explanation
- Missing an expressed intent to delay care
- Refusing a legitimate request that the rule set allows
Benchmarks
No benchmark card lists this capability.
Grading references
No grading reference is mapped to this capability.